Christian Ecology  Link's Home Page Home   What's on?    Ideas    About CEL    Resources    Sustainable Transport    Magazine    Links    Tourism    GMOs    Conf2007    Climate Change    ChurchLink    News    Search    Sitemap    email CEL

>From Norfolk Genetic Information Network (ngin),

Forwarded by Genetic Food Alert ....18 Maech 2002


---Please Circulate---





2. BBC interview with P V Satheesh - March 18, 2002.


1. For Immediate Release





Press conference: Monday, March 18th, 2pm,  Attlee Suite, Portcullis

House, Houses of Parliament


The UK Government is poised to spend 65 million to underwrite a

development scheme that will throw twenty million Indian farmers off

their land over the next twenty years. The scheme - called Vision 2020 -

focuses on agricultural 'development' in Andhra Pradesh and involves the

restructuring of farming to favour large industrial-scale agriculture,

increased mechanisation and GM crops. Representatives of a local

"citizens jury" from Andhra Pradesh will today visit the British

Parliament to call for a halt to funding of the scheme and present MPs

with further evidence of the draconian plan.


Vision 2020 is put together by the Andhra Pradesh State Government and

the management consultancy McKinsey and Company.  Both the World Bank

and the UK Department for International Development (DFID) have

earmarked funds to support the scheme which will transform all areas of

social and economic life. The scheme would ensure that 30% of the

current population (a minimum of 20 million people) would be displaced

from their land.


The citizens jury, organised by two leading UK research institutes in

partnership with Indian development charities, includes some of India's

poorest farmers. After considering evidence from 12 specialist

witnesses, including representatives of the GM industry and pro GM

academics, the citizen's jury unanimously opposed Vision 2020's strategy

of removing 20 million farmers from the land.


PV Satheesh, Director of the Deccan Development Society in Andhra

Pradesh, said:

"Vision 2020 is an aid package for big farmers and corporations.  We've

reached a fork in the road for farming around the world and the UK

Government is about to send the people of Andhra Pradesh down the wrong

track. Vision 2020 means huge farms, pesticides, mass mechanisation and

GM crops but offers nothing but a loss of homes and livelihoods to most

of the people who actually live and farm in this region."


A wide coalition of UK development and environment groups and charities

have come together with the Indian farmers in their call for support for

their sustainable agriculture and an end to UK funding of Vision 2020.

They include Christian Aid, ITDG, The Small and Family Farm Alliance,

Friends of the Earth and Greenpeace.


Full report:


For further information, please contact:

Deccan Development Society, PV Satheesh c/o Michael Hart +44 (0)7771


Christian Aid - Mark Curtis, +44 (0)207 523-2170

ITDG - Andrew Scott +44 (0)192 663-4400

Friends of the Earth - Tony Juniper  +44 (0)207 490-0336

Greenpeace - Charlie Kronick +44 (0)207 865-8228, mobile +44 (0)7801


Institute of Development Studies - Tom Wakeford - +44 (0)7966 170713 ?

report co-author

International Institute for Environment and Development - Michel

Pimbert, phone +44 (0)207 3882117 ? report co-author


2. BBC Radio 4 Today Programme, Monday March 18, 2002.


Interview of P V Satheesh by James Naughtie


JN:  The first UN conference on financing development is starting in

Mexico. The main debate there is going to be about aid - bluntly put -

'good or bad'? But here's an example of something interesting going on.

In one region of the world a sustainable farming group is actually

rejecting a British aid project that is worth about sixty-five million

pounds. It is going to lobby today to press the point.


P V Satheesh is a farmer and Director of the Deccan Development Society

in Andhra Pradesh, and he joins us now from Oxford. Why do you think it

would be better for you not to get the money?


PVS:  Normally, every aid [project] is supposed to be in the interests

of the poor. But if an aid goes directly against the poor then it is

better that the aid doesn't come at all.


JN: How would this work against the poor in Andhra Pradesh?


PVS: There's an agricultural policy called Vision 2020 in Andhra

Pradesh. And DFID is funding the Andhra Pradesh Government to the tune

of one hundred million pounds this year. Vision 2020 envisages three

things: number one is the consolidation of land-holdings, two is getting

in corporate agriculture, third is orientating agriculture to export.

Each one of them will make small and marginal farmers lose complete

control over their land and processes. And they will be absolute

destitutes at the end of it.


JN: Is it inevitable that the way that DFID gives the aid will mean that

it is spent in that way, rather than in a way that you think will help

poor farmers in the region?


PVS: Absolutely not. Aid agencies could be far more sensitive and listen

to the voices of the poor, which is what this process of Citizens jury

has done. It has given voices to some of the most neglected marginalised

people and they have very clearly said 'if you want to give the aid,

please give it in our terms, please give it with our consent', and if

that is heard by agencies like DFID then I think aid will work for the

better of the poor rather than for the worse.


JN: Do you think that you will have any success in persuading people

from DFID here, for example, that there is something fundamentally wrong

with the way the aid is used after it leaves the Government's bank

account here?


PVS: Absolutely. That is one of the reasons why we are here. With the

farmers directly talking to the British public and telling them that the

kind of aid that is coming here, to a government that wants to displace

something like thirty million farmers from their lands, which - if I

have to translate - is almost half the population of Britain being asked

to get out of their jobs - what impact would it have on their families,

livelihoods and communities? That's what is happening in the State of

Andhra Pradesh. And if the British public, who are the taxpayers, who

are assisting DFID to invest [in projects] outside their country get up

and say 'what are you doing with our money?', then I think agencies like

DFID have to sit up and listen, and do the correct things, rather than

doing the wrong things that they are doing now.


JN: P V Satheesh thank you very much.

Copyright 2002-2003 Christian Ecology Link     email: CEL
Home   What's on?    Ideas    About CEL    Membership    Resources    Sustainable transport    Magazine    Links    GMOs    Prayer guide    ChurchLink    News    New on Website    Sitemap